Lost Little Lamb

Cindy (Coco Lovelock) is worried because she's been having thoughts that the Church considers to be sinful, so she visits her pastor's home for guidance. But the pastor's wife, Mrs. Murphy (Silvia Saige), says that he isn't home right now. Mrs. Murphy offers to take a walk with Cindy while they wait for the pastor to return. As Mrs. Murphy takes Cindy by the hand and goes for a stroll, she reveals that she knows Cindy is here to talk to the pastor about having feelings of lesbianism.

Cindy is stunned that the pastor told her secret to Mrs. Murphy, but Mrs. Murphy changes the subject by saying she just remembered that she left cookies in the oven, and hurries Cindy inside. Once they're settled in the living room with a plate of cookies, Mrs. Murphy reveals to Cindy that she is also a lesbian, and that the pastor is gay.

Mrs. Murphy explains that she and her husband have been using his position to find people who are questioning their sexuality, so they can 'help' these people by having sex with them. Cindy is horrified, saying this goes against the Church's teachings. But Mrs. Murphy uses scripture to justify herself, saying that God loves everyone, including those who stray from the flock. Mrs. Murphy claims that she and her husband have been chosen by God to be shepherds to those who have strayed, and that she can help Cindy too...