The Cookie Jar

College Girl Gets Creampied by Both Boyfriend and Father During Visit

06-19-2018
10542
Comments: 12
Like 84
Dislike 12
Video Description: THE COOKIE JAR
COLLEGE GIRL GETS CREAMPIED BY BOTH BOYFRIEND AND FATHER DURING VISIT

SCENE opens on Travis and Amy, two college students, as they park their car in the driveway of a nice suburban house. The pair have been dating for months, but this will be the first time that Amy meets Travis' parents and she's anxious. She's so anxious, in fact, that Travis has been giving her pep talks throughout the entire drive. 'You shouldn't be so worried,' he says, handing her a bag from the truck. 'My parents are very accepting people. They're going to love you, no matter what!' Amy doesn't want to admit it, but she comes from a less affluent family and is very insecure about being welcomed into Travis' upper middle-class life. Even her luggage looks shabby.

Travis puts his arm around his nervous girlfriend and guides her to the front door. Just as he turns the knob, his father opens the door greet them. The men share a big bear hug while Travis' mom steps through the doorway to join in. Amy stands off to the side, awkwardly, until Travis notices and introduces her to his parents. His mom, Mrs. Greene, warmly takes Amy by the hand and invites her inside while his father offers to take her bags. This puts Amy at ease and she smiles shyly at the man before following her into the house. Mr. Greene holds the door open for them, sneaking a quick look at Amy's behind before he shuts the door.

CUT TO TITLE PLATE

The camera pans across the kitchen while the family chats and cooks together. Amy is in awe of how amazing Travis' parents are -- they seem to have the perfect nuclear family. Mrs. Greene is glamorous and sophisticated and his father, despite being quiet, is wise and successful. A very respected surgeon. She loves watching her boyfriend interact with them and thinks that it could be a glimpse into her own future! While the girl loosens up and begins more actively engaging in the conversation, Travis' father secretly watches her. He is having his own thoughts about the future.

CUT to that evening. The family sits around the living room sharing dessert. Mrs. Greene is telling Amy all the embarrassing stories from when her son was young, much to Travis' chagrin. As they laugh, Amy starts to notice Mr. Greene staring at her. They keep awkwardly making eye contact and it makes Amy nervous again. She wonders if his father dislikes her and, when he suddenly excuses himself to go to bed, she becomes convinced that it's because she's done something wrong.

CUT to Amy brushing her teeth and looking anxious in the bathroom mirror. She walks back into Travis' room and slips into bed beside him, while he jokes about sleeping together in the same room he had as a boy. They kiss, and Travis tries to get on top of Amy, but she is clearly preoccupied. She asks if they can just crash instead. It's been a long day. Disappointed but understanding, Travis says sure and snuggles up beside her. He turns out the light. Amy quietly asks her boyfriend if he thinks his father hates her. Travis laughs and tells her to stop being ridiculous. Of course, he doesn't hate her. He is just a quiet man. They go to bed.

CUT to Amy lying on her side, staring at the clock. It's 2am. The girl has battled insomnia for most of the night and decides to slip out of bed to clear her mind.

She walks into the kitchen to get a glass of water when she finds herself face-to-face with Travis' father. He is sitting in his bathrobe, eating milk and cookies. She is surprised to find him there. 'Sorry, I hope I didn't wake you,' he says, dipping his cookie in the milk. 'I couldn't sleep,' she mutters. He asks if she wants some and, not wanting to offend him, Amy says ok and sits down. She awkwardly starts eating the cookie while he stares at her. 'It seems like you really like my boy,' he says after a pause. She nods and tells him that Travis is amazing, the greatest guy she's ever dated. He keeps eating. 'I still think he has a lot of growing up to do,' Mr. Greene says. Amy looks down awkwardly at her milk. There is another long pause. 'But ... you are certainly the most beautiful girl he has ever brought home,' Mr. Greene continues. Amy blushes and says thank you, while he continues to stare at her. She begins to feel very hot in the face, as he adjusts his seat ever so slightly to lean in closer. 'I understand that you come from a difficult upbringing,' he asks. 'And that dating Travis has represented quite a change in standards for you. Am I correct?' Amy assures her boyfriend's father that it isn't like that, she loves Travis because of who he is, not what he has. Mr. Greene eats another cookie. 'But, you agree that standards are important?' He asks. She nods. He smiles at her. 'As a father, I hold Travis to extremely high standards. I'm sure you can understand why.' She nods again, starting to feel uneasy about where the conversation is going. Mr. Greene steps off his seat and stands in front of her. 'He isn't going to end up with just any woman,' he father continues. 'He is going to end up with someone who is the right fit for both him and our family.' Amy nervously whispers that she hopes that can include her. Mr. Greene smiles again. 'I think it can ... once you have earned my blessing.'

There is an awkward silence in the room, as the weight of Mr. Greene's insinuations hang in the air. Amy looks down at the bulge in his pajama pants. 'What exactly are you asking, Mr. Greene?' she mumbles. He removes his robe. 'I think I'm making myself quite clear, Amy.' He replies. 'If you want to be part of this family, you're going to need to start by impressing me.' Feeling overwhelmed, Amy meekly argues that she doesn't want to hurt Travis. Mr. Greene tells her that the boy will never find out. In fact, they never need to speak about this again. Just 10 minutes now and she will have his full approval and support for life. She hesitates. 'You do realize why Travis brought you here this weekend, right?' He asks. She shakes her head. The house is still. 'There is a ring in his bedroom with your name on it. A family heirloom. My grandmother's ring.' He replies. 'The only thing Travis is waiting on is my opinion.' He takes his cock out. Her mouth drops open, as she fully realizes what her future father-in-law is proposing. 'It's bigger than my sons, isn't it?' Mr. Greene asks triumphantly. She looks back up at him. She can't believe this is happening. 'He really has a ring?' she asks. Mr. Greene nods, smiling and starting to stroke her hair. Slowly getting to her knees, Amy tells her boyfriend's father that she wants to marry Travis. She'll prove it. If this is what it takes, then fine. He just needs to tell her what to do. 'You can start by calling me daddy,' he says and puts his cock in her mouth. First BG Sequence with Creampie. After he has cum inside of her, Mr. Greene pulls out and exits the kitchen leaving the girl naked and alone.

CUT to the next morning. Travis wakes up and rolls over to find Amy already awake. She is staring up at the ceiling, reeling from the guilt of her affair the night before. He kisses her good morning and, not wanting to give herself away, she kisses him back and he climbs on top of her to continue what he tried to start the night before. Second BG Sequence with Creampie. After Travis has come inside of his girlfriend, he holds her close. She tries desperately to hide her guilt. 'Do you know how much I love you?' he asks. Amy smiles. 'Probably not as much as I love you,' she whispers. Travis leaps out of bed, pulls a ring box from his drawer, and drops to his knees. He tells Amy that she is his soulmate, the only woman he has ever wanted to spend his life with and asks her to marry him. Breaking down, she says yes, and he kisses her, slipping the ring on her finger. Through her guilty tears, she chokes out that she loves him so much. He happily suggests they go and tell his parents the good news.

You Might Also Like...

« « 1 2
Comments
12 comments

Undo
PornFanWriter9
Enjoyed it, but if she knew she wasnt on birth control, she should have been more eager and persistent that her boyfriend give her a creampie to cover up the dad's seed who she feared impregnated her first.
2018-10-07 23:43
Like 0
Dislike 0
user_23434734
Her reluctance to betray her boyfriend and the dad's psychological and physical domination make this scene so hot.
2018-10-05 11:33
Like 1
Dislike 0
user_23420386
Can't wait for the next scene
2018-09-16 13:30
Like 0
Dislike 0
NightOwl61
Perfect execution of a loving boyfriend and a blackmailing father. Jaye played a perfect reluctant submissive. The pace of the sex was perfect in both scenes. Would love a follow-up where daddy comes to visit.
2018-09-03 19:34
Like 1
Dislike 0
user_23355273
Súper bueno
2018-06-24 16:38
Like 0
Dislike 0
pineman
Outstanding... Jay.e Tyler and Ricky all put in great performances... the ending left it open maybe for a followup video...  and indeed...  if she gets pregnant she won't know who the father is for sure...
2018-06-20 12:58
Like 1
Dislike 0
Kelton
Awesome scene. Can we get this type of daddy/daughter talk in all our family role play scenes, best I've heard in a while.
2018-06-20 11:41
Like 2
Dislike 0
BobBrent
Excellent episode proving you need in a hour long episode with three characters you need two scenes of MF, as in Jealous Brother, The Daddy Diddler, etc or full  sexual interaction between the three, as in The Fosters, Run Far Away etc.  Great story build up and the first MF scene had coercive seduction/blackmail, no foreplay but matter of fact from the father and the second MF with kissing, foreplay and even missionary from the boyfriend in a loving relationship made the episode exceptional. Two cream pies begs the question "who's the daddy".
2018-06-19 16:22
Like 3
Dislike 0
ZZT82
Craven  and Bree this was just outstanding  with a great story line...what made it so erotic was some fantastic acting by Jaye  when very slowly she really begin to enjoy it...and the ending could not have been better with the son getting his and of course a happy ending shes getting married but....(with a little apprehension in her face)
2018-06-19 07:29
Like 2
Dislike 0
user_23141046
Great scene as always i wish you would add BTS to the site i would love to hear the girls talk about the scenarios and what about them turns them on the most.
2018-06-19 02:13
Like 2
Dislike 0
Kelton
I second that would love to see a behind the scenes where girls talk about the scenarios and there acting
2018-06-19 09:46
Like 2
Dislike 0
« « 1 2
Experiencing problems with the site? Contact Support